Opens in a new tab
PigeonRocket home
Back to the blog

Published Feb 4, 2026 · BY STEPHANIE

Updated Nov 21, 2026

Pepsi Borrowed a Familiar Bear What the Campaign Reveals About Brand Associations

Pepsi Borrowed a Familiar Bear What the Campaign Reveals About Brand Associations

Pepsi's 2026 Super Bowl campaign put a polar bear in a blind taste test. The bear chose Pepsi Zero Sugar over Coke Zero Sugar, creating a very inconvenient moment for a character audiences could associate with the rival brand.

Subtle? Absolutely not. Easy to understand? That is where the interesting part starts.

Pepsi announced The Choice on January 29, 2026. The campaign offers a useful example of how a brand can construct a message around associations people may already bring with them.

The audience supplies part of the story

My reading of the creative is that the familiar bear makes the choice feel more consequential. A generic character choosing a drink would communicate a preference. This character invites viewers to read that choice through an existing rivalry.

The creative depends on recognition. If someone does not make that connection, they may still understand the taste-test story, but a layer of the joke disappears.

That is worth noticing when assessing your own brand assets. What does your audience actually recognize? A color, character or visual device only works as a shortcut when people have learned the association.

The campaign frames the comparison

The taste test gives viewers a specific decision criterion: product preference without visible labels. That framing is part of the strategy, not a neutral account of every reason people choose a drink.

For another business, the equivalent might be a clearly explained service comparison, a demonstration or a trial. The useful question is whether the comparison helps people assess something that matters to them.

Attention is one outcome to examine

Commercial success is a separate question. A memorable creative idea does not, by itself, establish sales impact, lasting brand change or commercial return.

To evaluate those outcomes, we would need the relevant evidence and a clear definition of success. My analysis here concerns the creative mechanism, not a verified performance result.

What smaller brands can use

Build recognizable assets through repeated, purposeful use. Make comparisons specific and supportable. Test whether people understand the message you think you are sending.

Borrowing a competitor's recognizable cues brings additional questions about confusion, permissions and legal risk. There is no need to imitate this particular execution to learn from it.

The useful lesson is that audiences arrive with existing associations. Good brand analysis pays attention to what those associations contribute—and what the evidence can actually tell us about the result.

Campaign reference: PepsiCo's announcement of The Choice.

For the identity decisions behind recognition, read about making a visual identity recognizable and useful. To translate an observation into an appropriate project, start with choosing the right brand help.

FROM THINKING TO DOING

Got a question of your own?

Tell us what you’re trying to understand, make or move forward.

Start a conversationMore from the flock